Two opened tins on a pale stone surface, one of octopus pieces in a red paprika sauce and one of small whole squid in black ink, beside a small dish of ink, a torn piece of bread and a lemon wedge

Do Tinned Squid and Octopus Go Bad? Shelf Life and the Ink

A sealed tin of octopus or squid keeps for years and an opened one for days, and the date stamped on the bottom is about quality, not safety. The reason is the heat the sealed tin went through at the cannery, and that heat is also why the contents can go to the plate cold. By the USDA figures for cooked octopus, 100 grams carries about half a day's iron and fifteen days' worth of vitamin B12. The ink takes its black from melanin. The Tinned Fish complete guide maps the whole category, and this page covers the octopus and squid part of it.

How long does an unopened tin keep?

Years. The USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service puts low-acid canned goods at two to five years if the can is undamaged and has been kept somewhere cool and dry. The FSIS puts foods treated with vinegar-based sauces or dressings in its high-acid category, at twelve to eighteen months. For either kind, the FSIS says temperatures below 85 degrees Fahrenheit are best and that the risk of spoilage rises sharply as storage temperature climbs. It advises against storing cans above or beside the stove or in a damp garage or basement.

What does the date on the bottom mean?

Quality. The FSIS is explicit that dating is not required by federal regulation for shelf-stable foods, that it is a quality marker, and that a shelf-stable product can be safely used after its sell-by date. The letters and numbers stamped beside the date are a packing code the manufacturer uses for tracking, not a date for the consumer. Whether a tin past its date is still good comes down to the state of the can.

How long after opening?

Three to four days in the refrigerator, per the FSIS chart for low-acid canned goods, and the same figure applies to seafood in retort pouches. Once the seal is broken, the tin is an open dish of seafood. The FSIS allows refrigerating the unused portion in the can but says to move it to a glass or plastic container to preserve quality and flavor. The opened tinned fish shelf-life guide applies the same rules to other tins, and the guide to leftover tin oil and sauce deals with what stays behind in the can.

How do I know a tin has gone bad?

Look at the can before the food. The FSIS warning signs are the same for every canned product: a bulging, leaking, heavily rusted or deeply dented can, a can that spurts liquid when opened, or contents with a foul odor. A deep dent is one a finger can lie in, and a sharp dent on a seam can open the seam to bacteria, so those cans are discarded. A small dent elsewhere on a sound can is not a problem, and surface rust that rubs off with a finger is cosmetic.

One thing looks alarming and is not. The FSIS notes that canned seafood occasionally contains small glass-like crystals of magnesium ammonium phosphate, called struvite. They form from natural constituents of the fish or shellfish after canning, and the FDA says they pose no danger.

Is a tin of octopus already cooked?

It has been heated in its sealed can, and that heat is the reason it keeps in a cupboard. Under US rules, a low-acid canned food is one with a finished pH above 4.6 and a water activity above 0.85, as 21 CFR 113.3 defines it. The same regulation defines commercial sterility as the condition, reached by applying heat, in which the food is free of microorganisms that could reproduce in it under normal storage without refrigeration, and free of viable microorganisms of public health significance. Ready.gov, the federal preparedness site, says commercially canned food may be eaten out of the can without warming.

That changes the work in the kitchen. Fresh octopus for the Galician fair dish simmers for 45 to 50 minutes once the water returns to the boil, according to the Xunta de Galicia's recipe. A tin can go straight to the plate cold. For a warm dish, the contents only need heating through, either in the sealed can in a bowl of hot water or gently in a pan with the tin's own oil or sauce.

What styles of tin are there?

Each style of octopus and squid tin has its own first use. None is a better or worse version of another; they are different dishes.

Style What it is First use Examples
Octopus in olive oil Cooked tentacle pieces in oil, sometimes with garlic Straight from the tin, or over warm potatoes shop José Gourmet Octopus in Olive Oil with Garlic; shop Ramón Peña Octopus in Olive Oil
Octopus in garlic sauce Octopus in a garlic sauce Over bread or rice, with the sauce shop Ati Manel Octopus in Garlic Sauce
Spiced octopus Octopus in spiced olive oil As a tapa with bread and something cold to drink shop José Gourmet Spiced Octopus in Olive Oil
Stuffed Octopus or squid stuffed and packed in oil or ink Halved over rice as a finished dish shop José Gourmet Stuffed Octopus in Olive Oil; shop José Gourmet Stuffed Squids in Ink
Squid in ink Squid in a black ink sauce Warmed and spooned over white rice shop Gueyu Mar Chargrilled Squids in Ink Sauce
Squid in a stew sauce Squid in a spiced stew sauce With potatoes or bread, like a small stew shop José Gourmet Spiced Calamari in Ragout Sauce
Smoked octopus Octopus smoked before packing On crackers with something sharp shop Wildfish Cannery Smoked Octopus
Pâté Cephalopod pounded smooth for spreading On toast, with nothing else shop José Gourmet Octopus Pâté; shop José Gourmet Cuttlefish in Ink with Shrimp Pâté
Ink in a jar Ink sold on its own as a seasoning To blacken rice or a pan sauce shop Conservas de Cambados Squid Ink in Jar

Is tinned octopus good for you?

By the USDA numbers for cooked octopus, it is rich in iron, vitamin B12 and selenium. The figures below are USDA FoodData Central values per 100 grams, set against the FDA's adult Daily Values. The octopus entry is cooked flesh. The USDA's standard reference entries for squid are raw flesh and fried squid. The table uses raw, and raw and cooked figures are not directly comparable, because cooking removes water.

Per 100 g Octopus, cooked Share of Daily Value Squid, raw Share of Daily Value
Energy 164 kcal 92 kcal
Protein 29.8 g 60 percent 15.6 g 31 percent
Total fat 2.1 g 1.4 g
Omega-3 (EPA plus DHA) 0.31 g 0.49 g
Iron 9.5 mg 53 percent 0.7 mg 4 percent
Vitamin B12 36 mcg 1,500 percent 1.3 mcg 54 percent
Selenium 89.6 mcg 163 percent 44.8 mcg 81 percent
Copper 0.74 mg 82 percent 1.89 mg 210 percent
Zinc 3.4 mg 31 percent 1.5 mg 14 percent
Sodium (plain cooked flesh) 460 mg 20 percent 44 mg 2 percent

Both animals are lean, at about 1 to 2 grams of fat per 100 grams of flesh by the USDA figures, so the olive oil or sauce a tin is packed in adds fat of its own. The species-by-species tinned fish health guide sets the omega-3 figures for each species side by side. The sodium figure for octopus is for plain cooked flesh, not a tinned product, so the number on the tin's label is the one that counts.

What about mercury?

Squid is on the FDA and EPA's Best Choices list, the lowest-mercury tier. The agencies say people who are pregnant or breastfeeding can eat fish from that list two to three times a week in four-ounce servings, and children twice a week in age-sized portions. In the FDA's monitoring table of commercial fish and shellfish, squid measured a mean of 0.024 parts per million across 36 samples. That is in the same neighborhood as sardine at 0.013 and shrimp at 0.009. Octopus has no row in that table and does not appear on the FDA advice chart.

What is the ink?

The ink is made in the ink gland, at the base of the animal's ink sac, and its defining component is melanin, in the form called eumelanin, according to a 2014 review in the journal Marine Drugs. In cuttlefish ink, melanin is about 15 percent of the wet weight and protein another 5 to 8 percent, and the review notes that melanin is best characterized in cuttlefish. Inks from six cephalopod species carry free amino acids at millimolar levels, with taurine making up about half or more of them in five of the six. Squid and cuttlefish inks also contain the catecholamines DOPA and dopamine, and cuttlefish ink contains an enzyme called tyrosinase. The same review names three dishes built on ink: arroz negro, the Basque txipirones en su tinta and the Okinawan ikasumi jiru. It also notes that most commercially sold squid ink comes from cuttlefish, chosen for its flavor.

The ink in a tin has been heat-processed with the squid. Ink sold on its own is a seasoning, spooned in to blacken rice or a pan sauce. Conservas de Cambados sells the ink in a 90-gram jar (shop Cambados Squid Ink in Jar), and Gueyu Mar packs chargrilled squid in ink sauce in a tin (shop Gueyu Mar Chargrilled Squids in Ink Sauce).

Are squid and octopus a shellfish allergen?

They are molluscs, and the answer depends on which country's rules apply. United States law recognizes nine major food allergens that must be declared: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. Molluscan shellfish, meaning squid, octopus, clams, mussels and oysters, are not on that list, so US labeling law does not require them to be flagged as a major allergen. The United Kingdom lists fourteen allergens, molluscs among them, and requires each allergen present to be emphasised every time it appears in the ingredients list. The UK list names crustaceans and molluscs as separate allergens. Anyone allergic to molluscs should read the full ingredient line rather than rely on an allergen statement.

Which animals are in the tin?

Squid, octopus and cuttlefish are cephalopods, a class of molluscs. The common octopus is Octopus vulgaris, called pulpo común in Spanish. The FAO's species sheet describes it as a solitary animal of the coastal seabed, living on rocky and sandy bottoms down to about 100 meters. It calls the species very common and of great commercial value. Industrial fisheries target it off Japan and the northwest African coast. In the Mediterranean it is fished by artisanal boats and also taken as bycatch by industrial, semi-industrial and artisanal fleets.

The common squid of European waters is Loligo vulgaris, the European squid, calamar in Spanish. The FAO describes it as a semi-pelagic animal of the continental shelf that migrates with the seasons between about 20 and 250 meters.

Common octopus European squid
Latin name Octopus vulgaris Loligo vulgaris
Spanish name Pulpo común Calamar
Where it lives Coastal seabed to about 100 m; rocky and sandy bottoms; solitary Continental shelf, semi-pelagic; seasonal migrations between about 20 and 250 m
Size Mantle up to 23 cm and weight up to 10 kg; commonly 10 to 20 cm and 1 to 3 kg Mantle up to 30 to 40 cm; commonly 15 to 25 cm
Caught with Bottom trawls, hand lines, traps, pots, beach seines, divers Bottom and midwater trawls, hand jigs, lamparo light nets, trammel nets, purse seines, gillnets
What reaches the tin Tentacle pieces in olive oil, garlic sauce or spiced oil; stuffed; smoked; pâté Whole squid in ink, stuffed in ink, or in a spiced stew sauce

Both FAO sheets describe the Mediterranean fishery, and the catch area for a given tin can lie elsewhere. José Gourmet, for one, states that the squid in its caldeirada tin come from the Atlantic and the Pacific.

Where does the octopus come from?

Galicia is the center of Spanish conservas, and the Galician rías shellfish guide explains why that coast became its capital. The octopus trade itself spans several coasts. FAO's GLOBEFISH market reports name Morocco and Mauritania among the largest octopus exporters and Spain, Japan and Korea among the largest importers, with Mauritania Japan's largest supplier in the first half of 2023. Spain also imported 242,876 tonnes of squid and cuttlefish in 2022.

The Conservas de Cambados producer guide covers one cannery on the Ría de Arousa in detail, and the José Gourmet octopus and squid producer guide covers another maker of cephalopod tins. Ati Manel packs octopus in garlic sauce in a 110-gram tin (shop Ati Manel Octopus in Garlic Sauce).

What goes into the price of a tin?

Start with the octopus. FAO's reporting through 2023 described tight octopus supply and rising prices as Moroccan quotas came down. The octopus in a tin is then cooked, cut, packed and sterilized before it is sold.

How to serve a tin of octopus or squid

The Galician fair plate. Polbo á feira is Galicia's fair-style octopus. In the Xunta de Galicia's recipe, the cooked tentacles are cut, laid on a plate and finished with coarse salt, pimentón, sweet or hot to taste, and a splash of olive oil. Tinned octopus takes the same seasoning. The tinned octopus and potatoes recipe warms the sealed tins in hot water and sets the octopus over boiled potatoes.

Squid in ink over rice. Warm a tin of squid in ink and spoon the squid and all its black sauce over plain white rice, with a squeeze of lemon. The squid in ink with rice recipe builds the full dish.

As a tapa. Octopus in oil or garlic sauce needs only bread, toothpicks and something cold to drink. The tinned fish tasting guide shows how to set a table of open tins.

Keep the oil. The garlic or spiced oil left in an octopus tin dresses warm potatoes or a pan of greens.

The shop is at 263 Josephine Street in Cherry Creek, Denver. Products ship nationwide from theambrosianpantry.com.

Sources & Further Reading

Back to blog

Shop this story

Shop this story (6)