A parchment-lined square pan of pale, fork-pricked shortbread cut into fingers, two lifted loose to show a sandy crumb, fine sugar scattered on top

Shortbread, and Why It Should Come Out Pale

Good shortbread breaks cleanly at the first bite and then turns sandy on the tongue, and it tastes mostly of butter. Nearly everything about the recipe serves that. The proportion is one part sugar, two parts butter, three parts flour by weight, with a little salt. There is no egg to hold a mistake together and no baking powder to cover one up. With so little in the dough, the butter decides how it tastes and the handling decides the texture. That makes shortbread the butter biscuit to learn first. Pressing a dough without warming it, and stopping the mixer the moment the dough holds, are skills every tart shell and sablé will ask for later.

The name tells you what the butter is doing. In a baker's English, "short" means crumbly, the same short as in shortening. Fat coats the flour's proteins so they cannot link up into the stretchy gluten network that holds bread together; Harold McGee lays out the mechanism in On Food and Cooking. So a shortbread that turns out tough has usually been overworked, and a crumbly one was mixed just enough.

The bread in shortbread

The name keeps the word "bread" because the thing used to be one. The usual history, repeated in McNeill's The Scots Kitchen and in popular accounts since, starts with medieval biscuit bread. Leftover bread dough was dried in a low oven into a hard rusk. Gradually butter took the place of yeast, and biscuit bread became shortbread.

A Glasgow cookery book catches that change partway through. In 1736 Mrs McLintock, a Glasgow woman, published Receipts for Cookery and Pastry-Work, the earliest known cookery book printed in Scotland. The two original copies known to survive are in Glasgow University Library. Her shortbread recipe is raised with barm, the yeasty froth from brewing ale. With yeast in the dough, it was likely closer to a rich, leavened bread than to the sandy biscuit made today. The yeast came out of the recipe later.

Some of the old habits stayed. Shortbread remains New Year food in Scotland, offered to first-footers at Hogmanay, and its New Year role is usually traced to the old Yule cakes. The three traditional shapes are still made: a thick slab cut into fingers, individual rounds, and a large round scored into wedges called petticoat tails.

Popular tradition holds that Mary, Queen of Scots, was very fond of petticoat tails. The name itself has two proposed explanations. One hears a corruption of the French petites gatelles, little cakes. The other traces it to "tally," a word for the pattern used to cut a petticoat, which would have made the biscuits petticoat tallis.

Pale in Scotland, gold in Brittany

Scottish shortbread is easiest to understand beside a relative across the Channel. Brittany makes butter biscuits with the same basic idea and different choices. Breton butter is traditionally salted. Brittany was exempt from France's salt tax, so farmers there could work the local Guérande salt into their butter, and from there it went into the caramel, as the region's story of salted butter, caramel and sardines tells it. The Breton sablé, named for sand after its crumb, is usually made with salted butter and egg yolk and baked to a golden color. The galette bretonne and the palet breton are two familiar forms; Filet Bleu's palets bretons (shop Filet Bleu Palets Bretons) are an easy way to taste one next to your own pan, and the Filet Bleu producer guide tells the house's story.

Scottish shortbread skips the yolk and bakes in a low oven. With no egg and low heat, the biscuit stays pale, and what you taste is butter, sugar and wheat that has dried out without browning. Once you know the difference, color is a good first clue to which tradition a butter biscuit comes from. The wider family, from these to the lean, twice-baked Tuscan cantucci, is mapped in the biscotti and butter cookies guide.

What goes in, and what each thing changes

Buy butter you would eat plain on bread, because in this recipe you nearly are. It makes up a third of the dough and its only liquid is the water in the butter itself: US standards require at least 80 percent milkfat, and European-style butters usually run a little higher. Cultured butter adds a faint tang. Salted butter works too, which puts a little of Brittany into the Scottish slab; just leave out the added salt.

Superfine sugar, sold as caster sugar in Britain, dissolves into the butter completely and gives the finest crumb. Granulated sugar works but can leave a slight crunch. Powdered sugar gives a softer, quicker-melting biscuit.

Rice flour is optional. Swap 40 grams of the wheat flour for white rice flour, which has no gluten-forming proteins and a slightly gritty grind. The biscuit gets a sandier finish, and the dough has less gluten to toughen if you overwork it. Historic UK's version of the recipe uses rice flour for exactly that slightly grainy texture.

The salt goes in the dough. A few flakes pressed onto the top before baking are optional, and they give an occasional sharp bite against all that butter. A broad, thin flake suits this, such as Maldon (shop Maldon Sea Salt). The flaky sea salt guide explains why crystal shape changes how salt tastes on the tongue.

Ingredients

  • 200 g (14 tablespoons) unsalted butter, cool room temperature
  • 100 g (1/2 cup) superfine (caster) sugar, plus 1 tablespoon for the top
  • 1/2 teaspoon fine sea salt (leave out if using salted butter)
  • 300 g (2 1/3 cups) all-purpose flour, or 260 g all-purpose flour plus 40 g white rice flour
  • A few flakes of sea salt for the top (optional)

You need one 8-inch (20 cm) square metal pan in a light color. It makes 16 fingers. The recipe doubles into a 9-by-13-inch pan; add 5 to 10 minutes to the bake and judge by color.

Method

  1. Get the butter right. Take it out of the refrigerator 45 minutes to an hour ahead. It is ready when a fingertip leaves a dent and the surface still looks matte. If it looks shiny or wet, it has gone too far; ten minutes back in the refrigerator fixes it. About 65°F (18°C) is the target if you have a thermometer. Line the pan with parchment, leaving an overhang on two sides to lift by.
  2. Beat briefly. Beat the butter, sugar and salt on low speed, or with a wooden spoon, for about a minute, just until the sugar disappears. Cake recipes want butter beaten pale and fluffy with air, but here that air would give you a puffy, cakey slab. Stop while the mixture still looks dense.
  3. Add the flour and stop early. Add the flour, and the rice flour if using, and mix on the lowest speed or fold with a spatula. For a while it looks hopelessly dry. Then it turns into damp clumps that hold when squeezed. At that point stop the mixer and press the clumps together with your hands. Any mixing after the dough holds makes the biscuit tougher.
  4. Press, prick, chill. Press the dough into the pan in an even layer, working into the corners, and smooth the top with the flat base of a glass. Prick it all over with a fork, right down to the pan, in rows about an inch apart. The holes let steam escape so the slab stays flat, which is also how crackers stay flat, as the crackers guide explains. Press on the salt flakes if you are using them. Chill 30 minutes while the oven heats to 300°F (150°C). Cold butter melts more slowly in the oven, so the edges hold their shape.
  5. Bake low and judge by eye and smell. Bake 45 to 55 minutes. At this low heat the slab dries all the way through before the top can brown, which keeps it pale. Doneness shows in three places. The top turns from glossy to dry and matte, the edges pull faintly from the pan and go the color of pale straw, and the kitchen smells of buttered toast. If the center still looks damp or feels soft, give it five more minutes. Underbaked shortbread tastes of raw flour. Overbaked shortbread loses its pale color and butter-forward taste.
  6. Cut while warm, then leave it alone. Rest the pan 10 minutes, then cut 16 fingers with a thin knife, pressing straight down. Warm shortbread cuts cleanly; cold shortbread breaks along its own lines instead of yours. Scatter the reserved sugar over the top and let the fingers cool completely in the pan. They are soft when warm and crisp as they cool, so do not judge the texture until they are cold. In an airtight tin they keep well for a week or more.

When it goes wrong

What you see Likely cause Next time
Hard and tough instead of crumbly Too much mixing after the flour went in Stop when the clumps hold together. Rice flour gives some margin
Puffed, cakey, open crumb Butter and sugar beaten too long, or too warm Beat about a minute, just until the sugar disappears
Greasy top, slumped edges Butter was too soft, or the chill was skipped Start with matte, dentable butter and give it the full 30 minutes in the refrigerator
Pale but pasty in the middle, floury taste Underbaked; at a low oven temperature color barely changes Wait for a dry, matte top and the toast smell, then add five minutes if unsure
Brown edges, slightly bitter Oven running hot, or a dark pan Check with an oven thermometer and use a light metal pan, or drop to 275°F and bake longer
Shatters when cut Cut after it cooled Cut 10 minutes out of the oven

Baking it in Denver

At altitude, cookies tend to flatten and spread. Colorado State University Extension's high-altitude advice is to cut fat and sugar slightly and to consider raising the oven by no more than 25°F to keep cookies from spreading. A slab pressed into a pan has little room to spread, so the recipe above should work in Denver as written. The adjustments matter if you roll the dough and cut rounds. Chill the cut rounds for 20 minutes before baking, and try a tablespoon less butter before you touch the oven, because a hotter oven costs you the pale color that is the whole point. In Denver's dry air the dough may look crumblier at step 3. CSU Extension advises a slight increase in liquid for Colorado's high, dry climate, so press it together with warm hands first, and if it still won't hold, add a teaspoon of cold water. The rest of the city's baking adjustments are in the Denver altitude cooking guide.

Putting it on the table

A strong cup of black tea cuts through all that butter. Mariage Frères English Breakfast (shop Mariage Frères English Breakfast) is one to try, and the English Breakfast tea guide covers how to brew it. At New Year, set a plate of fingers by the door for the first-footers.

Salted Breton palets, vanilla sablés and jam-filled rounds are all close relatives of this dough, with an ingredient or a temperature changed. Each still depends on cool butter and a mixer stopped early.

Sources & Further Reading

Back to blog

Shop this story

Shop this story (2)

Keep reading

More from The Pantry Kitchen